Finding the Perfect Fit: A Guide to Choosing the Right Sex Toy

May 13, 2025
Finding the Perfect Fit ShhhBox

Choosing the right toy starts with knowing what suits your body best. Learn how to select shapes and features that deliver maximum comfort and pleasure.

Let’s be honest—shopping for a sex toy should feel just as exciting as using one. But with so many buzzers, benders and bonkers gadgets out there, finding the perfect one can feel a bit... overwhelming.

Whether you're dipping a curious toe into the world of pleasure or you're already down the rabbit hole (pun 100% intended), this guide is your trusty sidekick to help you choose the toy of your dreams. And yes, we've linked all our faves so you can explore without getting lost in a sea of silicone. 

Step 1: What kind of pleasure are you craving?

Different strokes for different folks (literally). Here’s how to narrow it down:

  • External pleasure seeker? Say hello to Clitoral Stimulators. Think suction toys, bullets and vibrators that'll have your toes curling in seconds. 
  • Into deep, internal vibes? Check out Dildos or Rabbit Vibrators. These multitasking marvels hit all the right spots. 
  • Curious about backdoor play? There are plenty of beginner-friendly Anal Toys, booty-bliss guaranteed.
  • Spicy play for two? Dive into Couples Toys for next-level intimacy.

Step 2: What’s your experience level?

Whether you’re a curious cat or a seasoned adventurer, there’s a toy that’ll feel just right:

  • Newbies, we got you: Start with a no-fuss bullet vibrator, a simple dildo, or a silky-soft starter bondage kit. Bonus: our All Sex Toys page has plenty of easy-going options.
  • Mid-level mischief-makers: Try something with a little extra — think remote control toys, dual-stim vibes, or thrusting rabbit vibrators (oh yes, they exist).
  • Advanced adventurers: You’re ready for app-controlled delights, thrusting machines, or toys that look like they belong in a sci-fi film. Check our Remote Control collection if you’re into techy thrills.

Step 3: Pick your pleasure style

Here’s your cheat sheet for matching toy types to your vibe:

  • Vibrators: Bullet, wand, rabbit — we’ve got all the vibes. Explore the full Vibrators collection.
  • Dildos: Perfect if you prefer manual control or want something ultra-realistic. Dildos are your jam.
  • Strap Ons: Feeling switchy? Our Strap Ons are here for it.
  • Bondage & BDSM: From fluffy cuffs to full-on kits, our Bondage selection is ready to play rough.
  • Cock Rings: Rock your (or your partner’s) world with our firm yet flexible Cock Rings.

Step 4: Safety & satisfaction go hand-in-hand

  • All Shhh!Box toys are body-safe (read: non-toxic and phthalate-free).
  • Use water-based lube for silky-smooth play.
  • Clean your toys with toy cleaner or warm water and mild soap after each use. It’s not just hygienic — it makes your toys last longer too.

Step 5: Shop smart, play hard

Every Shhh!Box order is packed discreetly (no awkward postman convos), and we offer free UK shipping over £50. Returns? No worries. Our 14-day returns policy is there if you change your mind.

Ready to find your new favourite toy?

Browse All Sex Toys or dive into a specific collection that tickles your fancy. Need a curated surprise? Our iconic Shhh!Box toy kits are a great way to try something new.


Psst... don’t forget to check out our blog for more cheeky guides, top picks and pleasure inspo. You deserve it.